Our Menu

Our Menu

 

 

Pleasure House Location: Monday – Sunday 8am – 3pm | Red Mill Location: Monday & Wednesday – Saturday 8am – 3pm 

Shareables

 

Lillie Mae’s Knuckle Print Biscuits | 5

Two homemade biscuits served with house honey butter and seasonal jam

Firecracker Shrimp | 11

Crispy fried, rustic sauce, southern style coleslaw, Sriracha

Crabcake Bites | 15

Super lump crabcake bites, southern style coleslaw, rustic aioli

Fried Calamari | 14

Flash fried, baja sauce, rustic sauce

Scotch Egg | 11

Edwards sausage, bread crumb, smoked paprika, sauce vert

Avocado Toast | 11

Haas avocado, cherry tomato, grilled balsamic red onion, grapefruit vinaigrette, pickled radish, toasted ciabatta baguette

Butter Clams | 15

1lb. Little Neck Clams, butter, garlic, lemon, white wine, parmesan, parsley, crostini

Corn Chowder | 7

Bacon, onion, roasted red pepper, poblano, garlic, cream, potato

Mushroom Toast | 12

Pan Seared oyster mushrooms, parmesan mornay, egg* yolk, caramelized onion, arugula, pickled mustard seed, toasted ciabatta baguette

Crispy Brussels | 12

Crispy fried, bacon, parmesan, balsamic onions, breadcrumbs, balsamic glaze

Spoon Specialties

Shrimp & Grit Cake | 15 

Tomato, roasted red pepper, caramelized onion, Edwards sausage, griddled grit cake

Spoon Stack | 14

Our signature cloud like soufflé style pancakes served with seasonal fruit, whipped cream and maple syrup

– Not available on weekends, on holidays, or To-Go

Steak and Eggs | 18

New York strip steak*, two eggs cooked to order, served with home fries and choice of biscuit or toast

Biscuits and Gravy | 11

Buttermilk biscuits, Edwards sausage, sunny side up egg*

 

 Carnitas Hash   | 14

Braised pork, sunny side up egg*, roasted corn, roasted red pepper, tomatoes, queso fresco, potato, crema, cilantro, lime

Buttermilk Pancakes | 10

Three fluffy buttermilk pancakes, fresh fruit, whipped brown sugar butter, maple syrup

Dark Chocolate Waffle | 12

House whipped cream, chocolate sauce, fresh fruit

Chicken and Waffles | 14

House waffle, spicy buttermilk fried chicken thigh, hot honey

Stuffed French Toast | 15

Our decadent and innovative take on French toast made with brioche, filled with sweet orange crème anglaise, topped with Italian meringue, fresh fruit, candied walnuts and maple syrup

– Not available To-Go –

Rustic Meatloaf | 15
 
Hereford beef, Edwards sausage, garlic mashers, seasonal vegetables
 
The Good | 11
 
Two eggs* any style, choice of maple pepper bacon, Edwards sausage or Edwards country ham, served with home fries and choice of biscuit or toast
 
Greens

Add chicken 4 Add shrimp 5 Add salmon 6 Add steak 12

Rustic Salad | 7

Mesclun mix, cherry tomato, carrot, balsamic red onion, house made croutons, citrus vinaigrette

Salmon Salad | 16

Salmon*, spinach, romaine, red onion, radish, cherry tomato, candied walnuts, green goddess dressing

Classic Caesar Salad | 9

Crisp romaine, shaved parmesan, house made croutons, house caesar

Wedge Salad | 10

Iceberg lettuce, cherry tomatoes, bleu cheese, bacon, crispy onion straws, horseradish ranch

Eggs & Things

Edwards Country Ham Benedict | 15

English muffin, Edwards country ham, red pepper jelly, poached egg*, hollandaise, served with home fries

Avocado Benedict | 13

English muffin, Haas avocado, cherry tomato, grilled red onion, poached egg*, hollandaise, served with home fries

Carnitas Benedict | 16
English muffin, tomato, braised pork, salsa verde, poached egg*, hollandaise, fresh jalapeno, served with home fries

Crabcake Benedict | 19

English muffin, crab cake, green tomato, poached egg*, hollandaise, fried capers, served with home fries

Fried Oyster Benedict | 18

English muffin, Eastern Shore oysters, green tomato, poached egg*, hollandaise, capers, served with home fries

Filet Mignon Benedict | 22

English muffin, 4oz. petite filet mignon*, green tomato, maple pepper bacon, poached egg*, hollandaise, served with home fries

Loaded Omelet | 15

Edwards sausage, maple pepper bacon, Edwards country ham, roasted red pepper, caramelized onion, choice of cheddar, swiss, provolone or Colby jack, served with home fries

Veggie Omelet | 13

Seasonal vegetables, choice of cheddar, swiss, provolone or Colby jack, served with home fries

Handhelds

Served w/ French Fries

Pastrami Reuben | 14

Pastrami, sauerkraut and house made dressing on Rye

Haystack Burger | 17

Hereford beef* patty, lettuce, pickled green tomato, cheddar, bacon, house made BBQ, crispy onion straws, brioche bun

The Rustic Burger | 15

Hereford beef* patty, lettuce, caramelized onions, pickled green tomato and cheddar on a brioche bun

– add bacon 3 add an egg 2 add crab cake 8 – 

Oyster Po-boy | 18

Crispy fried Eastern Shore oysters, shredded lettuce, tomato, hoagie roll, baja sauce

Nashville Hot Chicken | 16

Crispy fried, pickles, southern style coleslaw, spicy breading, mayo brioche bun

Rustic Steak Sandwich | 18

Shaved beef tenderloin, caramelized onions, roasted red pepper, mushrooms, provolone, hoagie roll, au jus

Bay Burger | 19

Hereford beef* patty, crab cake, lettuce, pickled green tomato, baja sauce, brioche bun

Monte Cristo | 13

A decadent sandwich of Edwards country ham, turkey, swiss cheese on brioche, battered and fried, seasonal jam

Avocado Club | 15

Oven roasted turkey breast, maple pepper bacon, Haas avocado, balsamic red onion, lettuce, tomato and mayo

Crab Cake Sandwich | 19

Pan seared, lump crab, lettuce, pickled green tomato, baja sauce, brioche bun

Short Rib Mac Melt | 18

Smoked short rib, house made BBQ, gourmet mac and cheese, Texas toast

Cuban | 14

A Edwards country ham, roasted pork, swiss cheese, pickles and mustard on a rustic baguette

Sides & Extras

Toast | 2.5

Biscuit | 3

English Muffin | 3

Single Pancake | 4

Single Waffle | 5

Maple Pepper Bacon | 4

Edwards Sausage | 4

Edwards Country Ham | 6

Single Egg | 2

Home Fries | 4

French Fries | 4

Fresh Fruit | 5

Side Salad | 5

Side Caesar | 6

Garlic Mashers | 5

Mac & Cheese | 5

 
 *Consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry or seafood increases your risk of contracting foodborne illness – especially if you have certain medical conditions.
 
 
 
 
 
 

Wednesday through Saturday from 4pm – 9pm

Appetizers

Corn Chowder | 7

Cream based potato and corn chowder with bacon, onion, roasted red pepper, poblano pepper, and garlic

Fried Calamari | 14

Flash fried calamari, served with Baja sauce and Rustic sauce

Crabcake Bites | 15

Super lump crabcake bites, atop southern style coleslaw, and topped with Baja sauce

Firecracker Shrimp | 11

Crispy fried shrimp dipped in Rustic sauce, served atop southern style coleslaw, served with sriracha

Fried Green Tomato & Crab | 15

Fried lump crab and fried green tomatoes, served over corn chow chow, with cilantro and salsa verde

Butter Clams | 15

1lb Little Neck clams in a butter, garlic, lemon, white wine sauce, topped with parmesan, parsley, and served with crostinis

Mushroom Toast | 12 (V)

Pan seared wild mushrooms, with parmesan mornay, sous vide egg yolk, caramelized onion, mixed greens, pickled mustard seed, served on a toasted ciabatta baguette

Crispy Brussels | 12

Crispy fried Brussels Sprouts, with bacon, parmesan, balsamic onions, breadcrumbs, and drizzled with balsamic glaze

Bacon Wrapped Scallops | 18

North Carolina sea scallops wrapped in bacon, cooked in brown sugar and ginger, served with an herb cream sauce

Greens

Add Chicken $6 | Add Shrimp $6 | Add Salmon $7 | Add New York Strip $12

Rustic Salad | 7

Mesclun mix, cherry tomatoes, carrots, balsamic red onion, house made croutons, citrus vinaigrette

Wedge Salad | 10

Iceberg lettuce, cherry tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, maple pepper bacon, crispy onion straws, horseradish ranch

Classic Caesar Salad | 9

Crisp romaine, shaved parmesan, house made croutons, house caesar

Entrees

Gnocchi | 22 (V)

Wild mushrooms and gnocchi tossed in lightly creamed corn, spinach and sherry, topped with pickled mustard seed, and served with crostini (add chicken or shrimp $6, add salmon $7)

Cajun Gnocchi | 29

Shrimp, chicken, Edwards sausage, gnocchi, and Holy Trinity tossed in a Cajun cream sauce, served with crostini

Rustic Meatloaf | 19

A mixture of Hereford Beef* and Edwards sausage served over garlic mashers, smothered in mushroom gravy, and served with seasonal vegetables

Rustic Crab Cakes | 33

Lump crabcakes served with garlic mashers, seasonal vegetables, and lemon garlic aioli

Bourbon Bacon Filet | 39 (GF)

8 oz. Filet Mignon*, topped with maple pepper bacon and a bourbon glaze, served with garlic mashers and asparagus

Filet Mignon | 35 (GF)

8 oz. Filet Mignon*, served with garlic mashers, asparagus, and sauce au poivre

Smoked Short Rib Mac | 28

In-house oak smoked short rib tossed with cavatappi pasta, tomatoes and red onion, drenched in cheese sauce, topped with house made BBQ sauce and Panko bread crumbs

Blacked Salmon | 36 (GF)

Served over parmesan risotto, with seasonal vegetables

Potato Encrusted Salmon | 29 (GF)

Salmon coated in a shredded potato, garlic and dijon mix, served with parmesan risotto and seasonal vegetables

Shrimp & Grit Cake | 19 (GF)

Shrimp served over a griddled grit cake, served with a tomato, roasted red pepper, and caramelized onion sauce, with Edwards sausage

Beef & Mushroom Stroganoff | 24

Shaved beef tenderloin with a red onion, red wine, mushroom, garlic, sour cream sauce, tossed with cavatappi pasta, topped with diced pickle, served with crostinis

Smoked Short Rib Risotto | 32

In-house oak smoked short rib tossed in parmesan risotto with mushrooms, red onion, and au jus, topped with green onion and served with crostinis

Blackened Scallops | 36 (GF)

Blackened North Carolina sea scallops, served with parmesan risotto, asparagus, and a lemon caper beurre blanc

Handhelds

Served with French Fries

Haystack Burger | 17

Hereford beef* patty, lettuce, pickled green tomato, cheddar, bacon, house made BBQ, crispy onion straws, brioche bun

Bay Burger | 19

Hereford beef* patty, topped with a lump crabcake, with lettuce, a pickled green tomato, served on a brioche bun with a side of Baja sauce

Rustic Burger | 15

Hereford beef* patty, topped with lettuce, caramelized onions, pickled green tomato, and cheddar cheese on a brioche bun (add bacon $3 | add an egg $2) 

Oyster Po-Boy | 18

Crispy fried Eastern Shore oysters, over shredded lettuce and tomato, topped with Baja sauce, served on a hoagie roll

Crab Cake Sandwich | 19

Pan seared lump crabcake, with lettuce and pickled green tomato on a brioche bun, with a side of Baja sauce

Nashville Hot Chicken | 16

Chicken thigh fried crispy in a spicy breading, topped with pickles, southern style coleslaw,  and mayo, served on a brioche bun 

*Consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry or seafood increases your risk of contracting foodborne illness – especially if you have certain medical conditions. 

V = Vegetarian | GF = Gluten Free

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Thursday & Friday 3pm – 6pm

BBQ Sliders 8

Pulled pork, house made BBQ sauce, southern style coleslaw, slider buns

Scotch Egg 7

Edwards sausage, bread crumb, smoked paprika, sauce vert

Rustic Fries 9

Braised chicken, sweet pickled corn, scallions, rustic cheese sauce

Firecracker Shrimp 8

Crispy fried, rustic sauce, cilantro lime slaw, sriracha

Tomato, Basil & Burrata 10

Pickled blueberries, savory oat crumble, balsamic glaze

Fried Oysters 8

Three crispy fried Eastern Shore oysters, southern style coleslaw, rustic aioli

Corn Chowder 6

bacon, onion, corn, roasted red pepper, poblano, garlic cream, potato

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Crushes

Orange 7.5

Orange vodka, triple sec, fresh squeezed orange juice, sprite

Peach 8.5

Deep Eddy Peach vodka, peach schnapps, fresh squeezed orange juice,
sprite, cranberry juice

Ruby Red 8.5

Deep Eddy Grapefruit vodka, triple sec, grapefruit juice, sprite

Blueberry Lemonade 8.5

Deep Eddy Lemon vodka, blueberry vodka, triple sec, fresh squeezed lemon juice, club soda

Pineapple 8.5

Pineapple vodka, triple sec, fresh squeezed orange juice, pineapple juice, sprite

Arnold Palmer 8.5

Deep Eddy Lemon vodka, triple sec, fresh squeezed lemon juice, iced tea

Peach 8.5

Deep Eddy Peach vodka, peach schnapps, fresh squeezed orange juice, sprite, cranberry juice

Key Lime 8.5

Whipped vodka, fresh squeezed lime juice, gingerale

MIMOSAS

House Mimosa

Single 4 Double 7

MAKE IT MANLY 4

Classic, Grapefruit, Pineapple, Poinsettia

Sorbet Mimosa 

Single 4.5 Double 8

Strawberry, Raspberry, Orange, Mango

SpoonerMosa 8

Cruzan Passionfruit rum, champagne, fresh squeezed orange juice

Build Your Own Mimosa

Regular 17 Sorbet 21

One bottle of champagne and two flavor choices

– JUICE – Classic, Grapefruit, Pineapple, Poinsettia

– SORBET – Orange, Mango, Raspberry, Strawberry

Bloody Marys

GARNISHED W/ OLD BAY RIM, CELERY AND LIME

Rustic Mary 6.5

House vodka, Zing Zang

Cucumber Bloody 8.5

Effen Cucumber vodka, Zing Zang, cucumber sliver

Bacon Bloody 8.5

Titos vodka, Zing Zang, maple pepper bacon

Zesty Bloody 8.5

Ghost Pepper vodka, Zing Zang

Cereal Shooter Flight

EVERYONE LOVES CEREAL FOR BREAKFAST!

Peanut Butter Crunch, Apple Jacks, Fruit Loops, Cinnamon Toast

Lemonades

Rustic 8.5

Deep Eddy Lemon vodka, lemonade, lavender simple syrup, raspberry sorbet, club soda

Pink Cadillac 8.5

Champagne, lemonade, tequila, grenadine, triple sec, lime

– Sugar or salt rim

Loopy 8.5

Loopy vodka, Cruzan Passionfruit rum, lemonade

Cucumber Melon 8.5

Effen Cucumber vodka, Watermelon Pucker, lemonade, sprite

Old No.7 9.5

Jack Daniels Old No.7, lemonade, lemon

BEER

Bottles

Bud Light 4  

Budweiser 4

Miller Light 4

Coors Light 4

Michelob Ultra 5

Corona 5

Corona Light 5

White Claw 5

Drafts

Devils Backbone 7

Vienna Lager

Lagunitas 7

IPA

Cape Charles 7

Assateague Island – New England IPA

Bluemoon 7

Belgian White Ale

Wine

SPARKLING

La Marca Prosecco Italy

Glass 9 – Bottle 34

WHITES

Hayes Ranch, Chardonnay California

Glass 7 – Bottle 24

Parducci, Chardonay California

Glass 9 – Bottle 34

J Vineyards, Pinot Gris California

Glass 10 – Bottle 36

Proverb, Pinot Gris California

Glass 6 – Bottle 22

Sonoma Cutrer, Chardonnay California

Glass 12 – Bottle 40

Sea Salt, Sauvignon Blanc New Zealand

Glass 8 – Bottle 32

REDS

Tunnel of Elms, Merlot California

Glass 6 – Bottle 22

Broadside, Cabernet California

Glass 11 – Bottle 38

Chateau St. Jean, Pinot Noir California

Glass 8 – Bottle 32

The Crusher, Cabernet Sauvignon California

Glass 9 – Bottle 34

Portlandia, Pinot Noir Oregon

Glass 11 – Bottle 38